Driving is an everyday activity for millions across the nation, but it often comes with unexpected risks. A comprehensive study from Auto Express Magazine and IAM RoadSmart surveyed how drivers respond to different types of music — from metal to classical — while navigating the roads. This exploration sheds light not only on musical preferences but also on the state of driving across America.
State Rankings of Driving Habits
The findings reveal notable disparities in driving incidents depending on where one lives. Auto insurance inquiries, totaling tens of millions, were analyzed to assess driving behaviors from January 1 to August 31, 2026. The research categorized various violations per 1,000 drivers, looking at accidents, DUIs, and speeding as key metrics.
New Jersey emerged as the state with the most challenging driving conditions, recording a staggering 56.9 incidents per 1,000 drivers. It also had the highest accident rate in the study with 37.6 incidents per 1,000 drivers. Following closely in the rankings were North Carolina at 48.1 incidents and a tie between Massachusetts and South Carolina with 45.9 incidents each.
Rob Bhatt, an auto insurance specialist, highlighted that higher accident rates typically contribute to elevated car insurance rates. In fact, New Jersey’s auto insurance premiums are approximately 18% higher than the national average, a trend likely influenced by the state’s significant crash statistics.
California’s Driving Behavior
California found itself in a somewhat neutral position, ranking 21st with 33.7 driving incidents per 1,000 drivers, which places it just above the midpoint in the national standings. However, the state ranked as the sixth-highest in terms of accident rates, trailing behind New Jersey, Massachusetts, North Carolina, Maine, and South Carolina. Alarmingly, California shared the fourth spot with Iowa for having the highest incidence of DUIs.
In response to these findings, the California Insurance Commissioner announced plans to prohibit insurance companies from considering marital status when determining premium rates, potentially paving the way for fairer insurance pricing.
On the Other Hand: The Best Drivers
On the opposite end of the spectrum, Michigan reported the fewest driving incidents, with just 22.1 per 1,000 drivers, and the lowest accident rate at 11.5 per 1,000 drivers. This is a stark contrast to states like Hawaii and New Mexico, which also reported relatively low incidents but still faced varied insurance rates.
Despite these differences, it’s important to note that fewer incidents do not necessarily correlate with lower insurance costs. As Bhatt pointed out, while Hawaii offers cheaper premiums than the national average, Michigan’s rates are slightly higher, illustrating how various factors beyond crash rates influence insurance pricing.










