OESnews

A Gruesome Discovery: Mother and Daughter Charged in Cold Case Murder

A Gruesome Discovery: Mother and Daughter Charged in Cold Case Murder

In a shocking turn of events, Placer County deputies have apprehended a mother and daughter duo linked to the chilling murder of a man whose severed head was discovered in a trash bag. The arrested individuals are Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, and her mother, 75-year-old Georgia “Gwinn” Fitzmaurice. The victim, identified as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., was 73 years old at the time of his tragic death.

The Disturbing Discovery

On September 28, 2022, a dog walker stumbled upon a trash bag in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill, located roughly 55 miles northeast of Sacramento. Inside the bag was the remains of a human head, which led to an immediate investigation. This gruesome find occurred amidst the backdrop of the Mosquito wildfire that raged in the region.

Due to the advanced state of decomposition, the remains were initially unidentifiable. An autopsy was performed, and forensic specialists managed to create a general profile of the victim, even producing an artist’s rendering. Unfortunately, this approach yielded no matches when compared against missing persons reports. Additionally, DNA testing via the CODIS system also did not provide any leads.

The situation took a turn in January 2024 when detectives opted for genetic genealogy testing on the DNA. This investigation allowed them to pinpoint potential distant relatives of the victim, leading investigators to trace Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr.’s family.

A Web of Deceit

It emerged that Paul had never been reported missing and was last known to reside with his wife, Georgia, and their daughter, Mary, in Citrus Heights. The investigation unveiled a sinister plot where Mary was identified as responsible for her father’s death. Furthermore, both women conspired to hide his remains. According to Sheriff Wayne Woo, even after the horrific event, the mother and daughter continued to collect his Social Security benefits and California public pension.

The duo maintained a façade of normalcy, convincing their family and friends that Paul was still alive. They claimed he was a recluse, disappearing for days before returning home occasionally. This elaborate deception left many in their community unaware of the grim reality.

While significant progress has been made in the case, authorities have yet to reveal the motive behind the murder. It remains unclear where the rest of Paul’s remains are, as a search of the family’s residence yielded no further evidence.